What would B-P do?
Robert Baden-Powell founded Scouting over 100 years ago to fill a void. He took what he had learned in service to his country and adapted it for boys who clamored for an outdoor life—a Boy’s Life.
Over the years, B-P’s Scouting idea was filtered and further adapted and bureaucratized by men, most with good intentions, as the Scouting Movement became institutionalized in 100s of nations across the world. As they say, an idea is the raw grain of a movement, and as any other ingredient in man’s diet it is seldom recognizable by the time it becomes a “movement”.
We can argue if the Scout Association of the UK or the Boy Scouts of America (current or “improved”) or the Girls Scouts of America or any member of the World Organization of the Scouting Movement (WOSM) has remained faithful to B-P’s spirit and intent. How many angels can dance on the head of a pin?
There is no arguing that modern bureaucracies have changed essential elements of B-P’s Scouting for Boys. That fact is printed in plain black and white. The BSA has wandered far from the basics of the Game of Scouting, with warm fuzzys and merit badge factories and full-time institutional inertia. We can (and will) argue whether this is a good thing or not. And in the United States, this time of trouble regarding such a bureaucratic travesty as membership standards may be the perfect impetus to revisit the whole reason we became Scouts.
Why do you play the Game of Scouting?
As a youth, I never thought much about the difference between “Scouting” and the BSA. I knew B-P started Scouting in England a long time ago, and communist nations outlawed Scouting. When I returned to the BSA as an adult leader, I read up on the meaning of that purple fleur-de-lis on my uniform, and the fact that there are many different Scouting organizations, both within the WOSM and without.
The Traditional Scouting movement refers to a back to basics effort that returns Scouting to a style based on Robert Baden-Powell‘s model of Scouting; rejecting the trend of modernizing Scouting to appeal to more youths… In America, the term Traditional Scouting can also refer to “old-fashioned” Scouting in some form, as opposed to the Traditional Scouting movement. -Wikipedia
The BSA is only one player in the Scouting movement. Some alternate groups are more or less organized, more or less conservative or liberal, more or less “Traditional”. As a Scouter, this may be a time to stick with the BSA and work to bring the movement back closer to B-P’s ideas and ideals. As a Scouter, it may be time to plant your flag in another camp.
Either way remember: Scouting is a Game, and it is for the Boys.
- Morally Straight… No More. (johnscout.wordpress.com)